Ask the Analyst: Why Would Chinese Sugar Refineries Import at A Loss?

Insight Focus

  • Chinese refineries have been buying raw sugar even with negative margins.
  • Offtake has reached 4.3m tonnes for the year.
  • Will they continue to import with today’s margin of -160 USD/mt?

Strong Imports Despite Negative Margin

Chinese refiners increased their coverage of 2022 demand almost every time the No.11 raw sugar futures fell below 18c/lb. Therefore, this year’s raws demand has reached 4.3m tonnes, just 200k tonnes away from the target.

undefined

This is even though AIL import margin was negative during most of the year. So why would they import at a loss?

undefined

The first reason is that Chinese sugar refineries usually need to make use of all their Automatic import licenses (AIL) each year to ensure next year’s volume is not reduced.

Actual Margin Higher Than Paper Margin

The actual margin is higher than paper margin once spot premiums are included. We usually calculate paper margin, which is the price difference between AIL import cost and ZCE white sugar futures.

Example of AIL Import Margin/Loss

undefined

But there are 3 more factors to be considered.

1. Quality Premium

2. Regional Premium

3. Quota Imports

The national standard of Chinese white sugar is 150 icumsa, most of which are produced directly from sugar cane. Whereas the quality of refined sugar is usually better (60 icumsa) as it’s produced from raw sugar. Therefore, refiners can usually sell sugar at a higher price against the domestic whites.

undefined

These spot premiums fluctuate with supply and demand of domestic market.

Refineries also benefit from being in coastal China, closest to the major sales areas for sugar. This means sugar refiners have a regional advantage because they are closer to consumers and can save on logistics costs.

undefined

It’s Not Just Out Of Quota Imports

China allocates 1.945m tonnes of import quota annually, which is subject to only 15% import duty (compared to (50% for OOQ imports).

Around 1.5m tonnes will be allocated to raw sugar imports, among state-own trading sector (mainly COFCO) and private sector (mainly sugar mills). Some refiners also own domestic sugarcane mills, which means they also get some low tariff import quotas. This means they can use the quota import to compensate the loss of AIL import.

Example of Quota Import Margin/Loss

undefined

However, the RMB depreciated 15% in last 6 months. This means the import cost has surged significantly. With losses on AIL imports now exceeding 1000 RMB/mt, the spot premium and quota compensation are not large enough to incentivise refiners to import. The spot premium can only make the operation profitable when paper margin is at a small loss.

undefined

Sign Up For Your Free Account On Czapp

Want to receive free tailored notifications straight to your inbox?

Join Czapp

Rosa Li

Rosa graduated from Jinan University in 2012 with a bachelor’s degree in Marketing. Rosa joined Czarnikow in 2014 and has been an analyst for 7 years in our Guangzhou office managing the data capture, analysis and visualisation within the Chinese sugar markets utilising her skills in SQL, Python and VBA while also providing content for our platform Czapp. Rosa is also responsible for the localization of Czapp in China – Czapp WeChat, she also assists with the commercial marketing in China and works towards strategy with the trading team.

See More From This Author

India: Sugar vs Ethanol? 11th April 2024

  • Domestic sugar prices have strengthened.
  • Producers are still being incentivised to use C-molasses for ethanol production.
  • General elections are starting later this month.

Samia Ohiduzzaman

3 days ago

1 min